Dr Yunes Teinaz
Senior Environmental Health Officer London Borough of Haringey.
Health & Management Advisor to the Director General
The Central London Mosque & the Islamic Cultural Central Regent Park.
RSPH Fellows’ Lunch
Meat Crimes in the UK19 May 2004
The Royal Overseas League,
MEAT CRIMES IN UKSpeaker: Dr Yunes Teinaz
Ladies and Gentlemen: it is an honour and a highlight of my career to be invited, to talk to such an eminent audience. I would like to give you an overview of the present situation of Meat Crimes in UK.
Ladies and gentlemen You must have read the newspapers reports and seen the pictures of unfit meat and poultry on your TV screens concerning large scale operations involving the diversion of unfit meat into the human food chain. It was such a well organised illegal enterprise that I would be surprised if some of you have not eaten that meat.
After arms and narcotics, the trade in illegal meat is considered to be the third biggest illegal trade - estimated to be worth up to £1billion a year.
Meat crimes threaten public health, violate people’s religious belief and abuse their trust. It frequently involves cruelty to animals. The people who carry them out have no moral qualms ...
The trade is potentially international - but enforcement efforts so far have been hampered by a shortage of resources and lack of coordinated intelligence between the agencies involved.
Penalties available under food law are also inadequate to deter some persistent offenders who, in simple terms, can afford to pay the fines as overhead costs and are very good in exploiting the loop holes.
The largest public health enforcement operation in recent years, Operation Fox, which was co-coordinated by Rotherham MDC, is also likely to have import ramifications for enforcement. Recycling up to 1,000 tonnes of unfit poultry into the food chain in December 2000.
Environmental Health Officers that raided the plant were appalled to find rotting poultry in overflowing skips, destined for people’s dinner tables
An Amber-Valley DC operation into a similar pet food laundering crime led to an equally high profile Court Case.
The complex food fraud dating back to 1995, involved an estimated 459 tonnes of rancid and unfit poultry, which was diverted into the food chain, in some cases finding its way onto the shelves of high street supermarkets.
More than a million putrid and diseased chicken and turkey carcasses got into the food chain between January 2000 and March 2001. There was evidence that, in addition to low risk waste passing through the company, high risk waste – deemed unfit even for pet food – was being trimmed and repackaged to make it appear fit for sale as fillet or for ready-to-eat meals
The food trade and food enforcers collectively cannot be proud of the series of failures that allowed meat not even suitable for pet food to find its way into national food distribution.
Regulation of meat issues is extremely complex, with a large number of agencies involved, and it is too easy for criminals to exploit the gaps. As things stand, the potentially huge financial rewards far outweigh the risks of being caught.
What is the problem?
1. IMPORTED MEAT
Illegally Imported ProductsBush Meat- Antelope, Grass cutters (bush rats), bats, wild boar, primates (gorillas and monkeys), live crabs, Giant snails, Wally meat, and Poultry.
Dried and smoked meat of all kinds Snails Goat Meat Dried and smoked fish and shellfish
Methods of Smuggling
Commercial/Dispensed Smuggling Passenger Baggage Personal Imports In Personal Effects Concealed with Fruit/Vegetables Consignments via airports Concealed with other food stuffs in shipping containers Via other EU Member States Trucks Caravans
2. ILLEGAL MEAT
Diversion of unfit meat from pet food trade to human food chain Illegal slaughter: Mutton, Beef ,Cattle / feet’s, Smokies, and Poultry Unlicensed Cutting Plants Unlicensed Cold Stores Sale of non-Health Marked Meat Use of ‘Illegal Health Marks’ Licensed Plants Legal meat becoming unfit due to poor transport and storage Sale and handling of ‘Condemned Meat’ Freezing out-of-date meat and re-dating Misdescription Frozen meat thawed out and sold as ‘Fresh’ Mutton dressed as goat Non –Halal ( Haram ) meat sold as Halal
Responsibility of enforcing the legislation falls upon the Meat Hygiene service which is an executive Agency of the Food Standards Agency, whilst in licensed premises, in non–licensed premises local authorities enforce the legislation.
However many local authorities are not equipped to deal with this public health issue. Responsibility of enforcing relevant legislation use to be the duty of local authorities.
Since 1995 the responsibility of meat inspections was passed to the Meat Hygiene Service, and responsibility to enforce the same legislation was partly transferred to local authorities in the year 2000, under the Enhanced Powers Regulations.
The skills, the resources, and expertise of local authorities had been gradually eroded but they are now generally waking up to their responsibilities.
However, their enforcements in this field appear to be patchy.
In the London Borough of Haringey I have been enforcing the relevant law rigorously and vigorously single handedly. I wish I could show you some pictures of the samples of meat I have seized over the years. I thought about bringing some with me but I didn’t want to spoil your lunch .
After three hard working years I am moving on from Haringey to the London Borough of Hackney next month, leaving Haringey free from unfit meat. I am sure my colleagues will keep up the high standards and continue to protect the public health in Haringey.
The government departments like DEFRA, FSA, under pressure from the consumers, have also introduced some measures to combat the trade.
The Food Standards Agency has, at the recommendations of the Waste Food Task Force, already introduced staining of high-risk poultry waste to prevent it entering into the human food chain. An Illegal Meat Task Force has also been set up to help Environmental Health Officers combat large-scale food frauds.
However it’s failing to introduce controls that might prevent another fraud on the same scale as the Agency is not forcing the local authorities to take more stringent actions.
I am sure our colleagues in the Food Standards Agency will continue to introduce more suitable measures to curb this rotten trade but I would urge your good selves to use your recognised status to bring about changes to enable my colleagues within the profession to protect public health in more effective manner.
Thank you very much.
I hope you were able to understand my poor English because I always think in Arabic and translate in my head in English afterwards.