Return to warmwell.com       About vaccination against foot and mouth

Email from Roger Breeze September 26 2007

Earlier this week I was contacted by a major UK Media organization that wanted to know if I was willing to comment on the failure to use vaccine or rapid tests in the current UK FMD debacle. This was my reply. I thought these comments might be of interest to your readers who are also asked for responses.

"Can I suggest that 6 years after the debacle of 2001 and with renewed attention stimulated by avian influenza, the recent small FMD outbreak and first discovery of Bluetongue it is time for a serious conversation with UK farmers and the public about the realities of infectious diseases in today's world of rapid global travel and trade? I am happy to talk to you about rapid FMD testing for UK but this would be a conversation about whether the Titanic's deck chairs should be stored deep in the hold or close to the sun deck whilst sailing in iceberg-filled waters.

I attach a recent paper (1) that I wrote for the International Office of Epizootics (the World Trade Organization-like body that regulates international trade in animals and animal products). This sets out my views and how to pay for them. You will also find various letters of mine on www.warmwell.com.

I know you are busy so let me summarize. The current issue is not should the government use rapid FMD tests or should it vaccinate animals. The issue is that 6 years after 2001 the UK still does not have any rational concept of how to control highly-infectious livestock diseases that quickly spread across national borders.

  1. UK is not the island it was until the mid-1900s - the Channel and distance from infected countries are no longer barriers to introduction of dangerous diseases. Unless the national policy is to wait like a deer in the headlights until the next introduction (Bluetongue!), Gordon Brown should trigger and lead an EU and international effort to remove these diseases at their sources in the developing world. Pirbright and UK science and business would play significant roles in this effort.

    This goal is quite achievable in our lifetimes. In 1880, Louis Pasteur vaccinated the fist child against rabies. At that time he would never have believed that by 1980 we would be vaccinating the wild animals of the forests of Europe and today can contemplate eradication of a disease that has terrified people for centuries. Rinderpest, once the world's most feared cattle disease that killed many more animals in Europe than the Black Death killed people, has now been globally eradicated and for tens of millions of dollars only.

    In the late 1940s and early 1950s there were 40,000 to 50,000 FMD outbreaks per year in Europe (40,000 to 50,000) yet by 1990 the disease was eradicated, even with the technologies of the time.

  2. UK should also have effective processes to keep these diseases out through screening of travelers and imports - these costs should be paid by a levy on international travelers and trade. Farmers and livestock owners cannot do this task, it is an essentially governmental undertaking.
  3. UK should adopt policies on countering these epidemic diseases that minimize costs to the UK economy as a whole, not just to livestock owners. These policies should be implemented with the best available technologies that will support close to real time disease surveillance, reporting, detection and response.
  4. Livestock owners reporting the first cases of foot and mouth or other diseases of concern should be rewarded handsomely. Those farms that are infected in the next week or two should also receive public funds to encourage reporting. But after that livestock owners would have to rely on private insurance not the public purse - I do not believe it is the responsibility of the public to compensate them for a business risk, just as it is not public policy to buy someone a new computer when they have downloaded a malicious virus.
  5. I fully support the right of UK livestock owners to choose their foot and mouth control policy and to pay for that policy and its consequences. Nothing is more clarifying than to put one's money where one's mouth is. Such a policy would keenly focus the UK livestock industry on the scientific facts and serious discussion.
Sadly many livestock owners are laughably uninformed about issues critical for their own survival. For example, on September 23, BBC ran a story about a diary kept by Mr. Angus Stovold, a cattle owner in Surrey. He stated that he would never be able to sell his pure bred cattle if they were vaccinated against FMD. Utter nonsense! I would have been very inspired - and you would be having a very different public debate in UK - had Mr. Stovold's diary read as follows: I do hope your organization decides to look at the bigger picture and not just soundbites.

Reference

1. Technology, pubic policy and control of transboundary animal diseases in our lifetimes. R. G. Breeze. Res. sci. tech.Off.int.Epiz. 2006, 25 (1) 271-292 (available at http://www.oie.int/eng/publicat/rt/2501/A_R2501_BREEZE.htm)." Regards, Roger Breeze

 

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

 

ARCHIVE 2001 -2007

Fields of Fire witness accounts of 2001

Foot and Mouth policy 2001 - opinions

FRONT PAGES

Warmwell menu

FMD Front Page Current

General Archive Page (new window)

Archive August 2007 Surrey outbreak - stage 1

Archive July 2007

Archive June 2007

Archive May 2007

Archive April 2007

Archive March 2007

Archive February 2007

Archive January 2007

Archive December 2006

Archive November 2006

Archive October 2006

Archive September 2006

Archive August 2006

Archive July 2006

Archive June 2006

Archive May 2006

Archive April 2006

Archive March 2006

Archive February 2006

Archive January 2006

FMD Front Page September 2005 - Dec 2005

FMD Front Page Oct 2004 - August 2005

General Front Page (includes other and related items)

Front Page Autumn 2004

Front Page Summer - October 2004

Warmwell front pages Spring 2004

Warmwell front pages Oct 03 - Jan 04

Warmwell front pages Sept 2002

Warmwell front pages August 2002

Warmwell front pages June / July 2002

Warmwell front pages - May / June 2002

Warmwell front pages - April / May 2002

Warmwell front pages - March / April 2002

Warmwell front pages - the earliest pages in 2001 - March 2002