In Search of the Truth


PO Box 67 High Wycombe Buckinghamshire HP15 6XP

Telephone: +44 (0)1494  711649 Fax: +44 (0)1494  717265




29 March 2002


Peter Davies Esq

Chief Executive

Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals

Wilberforce Way

Southwater Horsham

West SussexRH13 7WN




Dear Sir


A worrying matter has come to our attention and we would very much appreciate hearing from you with answers to the following questions:

1. How many related cruelty cases have you attempted to take to court during the course of the Foot and Mouth outbreak in the UK in 2001 and with what results?

2. How many cases have you taken under Section 1 Suffering of the Protection of Animals Act 1911 through to the full span of the legal 6 months limit before announcing that you will drop the case ?

With the innumerable instances of cruelty highlighted by the press and witnessed by so many people, it is with dismay that we cannot find one instance where the RSPCA has taken any case to court, let alone follow one through to its successful conclusion.

Many times we ourselves were contacted by people on mobile phones, desperate to get the RSPCA to a scene where outstanding cruelty was taking place.  On rare occasions we or they succeeded.  Mostly (and these things rarely happened during convenient 'office hours' ) we drew blanks, receiving either recorded voices telling us the offices were closed, or desperate sounding telephone operators saying they could 'make a note but there is nothing more they can do.'  Or  'that MAFF would not allow them on the land and therefore they would be contravening the law were they to insist'.  The idea of setting up an emergency service at the Horsham Office was treated with ridicule.



The main purpose of the FMD Forum, is to look into the scourge of  FMD and other animal diseases, with a view to steering the authorities into adopting into their legislation, modern methods through the use of modern science.

Obviously animal welfare and the individual treatment of the sentient animals involved has to be of prime consideration; particularly in the light of so many rules and regulations, which at present allow these aspects to be overlooked in favour of  trade or political advantage.

In not being seen to be seeking to get these laws modified, the RSPCA has been acquiescing to the dictats of governments, rather than carrying out their duties of protecting the animals from being cruelly terrified, contrary - we suppose - to the terms of their Royal Charter.


Yours faithfully





Alicia Eykyn

Executive Director

FMD Forum




Chairman: Bill Eykyn

Executive Director: Alicia Eykyn Veterinary Director: Wendy Vere MA VetMB MRCVS Research Director: Jon Dobson

Founder Members:

Dr Keith Sumption PhD MAVet.MB MRCVS, Dr Ruth Watkins BSc HonsMBBS MSC MRCP MRCPath (Clinical Virologist), Dr Noel Moet PhD MRCVS

Dr Sheila Crispin MAVetMB BSc PhD DVA DVOphtha MRCVS, Dr James Irvine FRCP(Ed)FRCPathDscFRS(Ed)FID FIBiol, Dr AJBeale MD FRCpath

Dr Jim Hutchison MD FRCP(G) FRCPath, Dr Sarah Binns MAVetMB MSc PhD MRCVS, Paul Roger Bvet Med BSc MSc DSHPCertWEL MRCVS, Tony York

Mary Marshall, , Suzanne & Peter Greenhill, Alex Bentley, Elwyn Williams, Dr Richard Lawson MB BS MRCPsych, Prof.P.Midmore Bsc Econ PhD, Pat Dent

Ken Tyrrell BAB.Sc(Vet) MRCVS,Dr Susan Haywood PhD BVSc MRCVS, Alayne Addy solicitor, Barbara Jordon solicitor,Stephen Tromans barrister, Phil Owen

Leolin Price CBE QC, Lady Lucinda Lambton, Allan and Rosie Beat, The Countess of Marr, Joan Gambage, Rosemary Upton, Tom Griffith-Jones , Arwyn Davies

Julia Curry, Roy Miller, Jane Barribal, Richard Mawdesley, Mary Critchley, Dr A Richardson Bvet Med PhDMRCVS, Prof D C EllwoodBScHons PhD FRCS FIBiol

Pat Walker,Roger Windsor MBE BVM & SBSc MA MRCVS,Christopher Stockdale, Philip Straker, Dr Peter Poll DVM(Holland),Abigail Woods MAVetMB MRCVS

Oaklands Park Farm, Peter Wood BvetMed MSc MRCVS,Vets for Vaccination, Patrick Holden, Soil Association, Michael Hart, Small and Family Farms Alliance